News RSS Feed



click here for Your Neighbourhood

Vatican questions Virgin Mary vision

9:29am Tuesday 25th September 2007

comment Comments (3)   Have your say »


The Vatican has refused to recognise a religious group formed after an apparition of the Virgin Mary was seen in a pine tree.

The Family of Divine Innocence was formed in 1984 after 67-year-old Patricia de Menezes claimed she saw The Madonna in the tree near her Surbiton home.

“As loyal Catholics we will do all we can to communicate accurately the Way of Christ’s Divine Innocence to the authorities of the Catholic Church.”

The vision was nicknamed Our Lady of Surbiton.

But in a statement the Vatican said the group has no recognition from the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Southwark or the Holy See.

The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which investigates doctrinal orthodoxy for the Vatican, launched an investigation into the group.

It raised four areas of concern, including the use of inappropriate words and phrases attributed to Jesus and a demand from the group that aborted foetuses be considered martyrs.

In a statement released this morning the group said they were surprised by the findings of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

The statement reads: "As loyal Catholics we will do all we can to communicate accurately the Way of Christ's Divine Innocence to the authorities of the Catholic Church."

It adds: "We recognise and are grateful to the Church for her uncompromising stance against the evil of abortion'. It is our desire that it considers the martyrdom of these children as a witness to the truth of the right to life of unborn human beings."

The Most Rev Kevin McDonald, Archbishop of Southwark, said: "In view of the very serious concerns raised by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, it must be clearly stated that the Divine Innocence has no recognition or approval whatsoever either from the diocese of Southwark or the Holy See and that there is no ecclesiastical approbation for Catholics to meet as the group known as Divine Innocence."


Your Say YourWimbledon Guardian

Kevin Rowles, says...
6:56pm Wed 26 Sep 07

The Vatican hasn't "questioned" Patricia de Menezes' visions - it has unequivocally condemned them (for full statement of condemnation see http://www.rcsouthwa
rk.co.uk/statement_c
di_2.html ). But de Menezes has twisted this by stating that she is being "loyal" by continuing to peddle what the legitimate authorities in Rome have declared to be false. Who is she being loyal to? Obviously not the Church.

Jock, London says...
2:35pm Thu 27 Sep 07

The real question should be "Who cares?"

Lot of religious nonsense built around a daydream, if you ask me.

chazz, surbiton says...
2:53pm Tue 2 Oct 07

If a full investigation into the financial dealings that the de Menezes are involved with, people would see clearly why Patricia and her son are steadfastly refusing to be obedient to the authority of the Church. Scratch a little below the surface and you will see the truth behind this woman and her close knit "family" She and her son have properties, not only in surbiton, but all over the world too! If she really cared about her faith, she would at once obey the Church, sell all the property that her members have paid for and give it to the anti-abortion charities. Now that would show a true christian spirit!

Comments are closed on this article.

Local Links


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »